Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1100 Jefferson Rd
Rochester, NY 14623

Phone: (585) 424-5637

Website

Neighborhood: Rochester

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza Large 18" $25.27
• A large hand tossed Thin Crust Pizza. A “Crisp” crust, yet soft in the middle and is meant to be enjoyed by folding in half. Listen for that “Crunch” as you fold your Joe’s Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza!
• Garlic Knots (3) $3.27
• Knots Garlic Butter and Romano cheese
• Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza Medium 14" $21.97
• Brooklyn Thin Crust Medium 14" Cheese Pizza
• 12 Jumbo Chicken Wings $17.59
• Fresh Oven Roasted Jumbo Chicken Wings. Never deep fried. And with O Trans Fat. Try our Home-Made BBQ Sauce with Ghost Peppers or our Buffalo Sauce. We also support local sauces from right here in Rochester, Boss Sauce, Country Sweet and also the original Chicken Wing sauce, Frank’s Hot Sauce.
• Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza Xl 20" $29.67
• A large hand tossed Thin Crust Pizza. A “Crisp” crust, yet soft in the middle and is meant to be enjoyed by folding in half. Listen for that “Crunch” as you fold your Joe’s Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza!

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

See More Photos

 See All Photos

See All Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

Write a Review

  4.1 stars - Based on 33 reviews

#70 out of 1533 restaurants in Rochester

#3 of 149 Pizza in Rochester

5 star				9 reviews	27%
4 star				19 reviews	58%
3 star				4 reviews	12%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	3%

Top Reviews of Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

12/27/2024 - Megan I.
The pizza at this establishment may be pricier than other options, but the quality is evident in every bite - definitely worth the splurge. The friendly staff and delicious food, such as the hot and fresh slices and mouthwatering garlic knots, make it a standout choice for a satisfying meal experience.

04/24/2024 - Little G.
delish!

12/12/2021 - Private
Awesome experience the first time. Sent a friend in to pick up a couple of slices, it was his first time there.
Super nice kid that worked there said "hey we are having a special buy one get one free" so my friend picked another slice and said I'll take one of those. Super nice kid says "you should get another one it's free".
The manager comes over upset and says to the employee "I'll take care of this" and rings my friend up. It came to $21.
My friend comes home and tells me this whole story asking me how much one slice is. I'm thinking $10 bucks is a Lot for a slice but what do I know. I pull out a menu they gave me and see that at the most a slice is $5. So I call the shop. The manager answers. So far I'm thinking this is a misunderstanding and have no idea I'm talking to the manager.
However, as soon as I get to the part in the story where the nice kid tells us about the special the manager stops me dead in my sentence and announces: OUR BUY ONE GET ONE FREE ENDS AT 5. (If you are reading this, think about that for a minute, maybe even reread it since it's really unreal)
Confused, i look at the time it's 5:15. Then I'm thinking why am I even looking at the time, we didn't even know about this special, and I already told him the kid sold my buddy on a special. I reply "I'm trying to tell you a story". He continues to interrupt me.
So it turns out the manager charged my buddy full price to try to make some point. I try to explain to this guy we don't even know anything about buy one get one free and he keeps interrupting me.
So I walk over to the store and say " hey buddy, you aren't letting me talk, at this point I just want my money back". He continues to flap his lips about how the special ends at 5. I say dude it's obvious you already know what happened since you won't let me talk. So you tell me - Why charge a customer full price when you just watched your employee sell him on the buy one get one? I did tell him to go back to the prison he came from. I'm over it now. I hope others know they are not alone if they experience something similar. The guy ALREADY knew what happened. He also 'was treating the staff like crap.
On a good note, The pizza is crazy good. There isn't any better pizza in town. Absolutely delicious. The other employees are super awesome. I would still say to get your pizza there. I didn't get my money back. I gave them the pizza back. I stopped letting the manager talk after realizing he was under qualified. The manager told me he "would only give me my money back if I let him talk". Oh really? Keep your money buddy. You never let Me talk. You already knew what you did. I'll pay the $21 for you to shut your mouth and more. It's a good investment. The pizza is good. Manager is a petty thief.