Delivery
Yes - call for delivery info.
Payment
Credit Cards Accepted
Parking
Parking Lot
Good for Kids
Yes
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
Beer and Wine
Reservations
No
Add a description here.
| 5 star |
|
|
21 reviews | 40% | |
| 4 star |
|
|
23 reviews | 43% | |
| 3 star |
|
|
4 reviews | 8% | |
| 2 star |
|
|
1 review | 2% | |
| 1 star |
|
|
4 reviews | 8% |
06/02/2025 - Iris S.
I used to avoid Upper Crust because of the old management, but returning recently reminded me how great their thin crust pizza is-perfectly foldable with plenty of tasty toppings and a delicious sauce. The staff here are genuinely friendly and welcoming, always ready with good recommendations and quick service, which makes the experience feel personal and local. While the cheesy bread didn't quite hit the mark and the restrooms could use some attention, the pizza quality and overall atmosphere keep me coming back, especially for takeout.
06/24/2024 - Tera Y.
FOOD IS ALWAYS GOOD
05/29/2024 - Sterling R.
I used to avoid Upper Crust due to poor service, but giving them another chance was worth it. The thin, foldable crust with flavorful sauce and generous toppings made me a fan. The friendly staff and unique experience definitely set this pizzeria apart from chains.
09/14/2021 - joanne
stood at cash register thay just looked at me for 10 minutes wow really bad service i walked out
08/15/2021 - MenuPix User
Nice folks ... yet peperoni pizza was light with peperoni ... not a great value
05/25/2021 - Gail S
The sweetest, kindest people! And absolutely, uniquely delicious homemade pizza. The crust is divine, as is their slightly sweetened tomato sauce. Handwritten notes of care... and scribbled smiley faces on my bags. Due to Covid we've not yet met. But I will be making a vaccinated visit SOON! I would give Upper Crust 10 stars if I could. Please try this locally owned business, if you haven't already. 💕ðŸ™ðŸ˜Š
01/06/2021 - Ann
I am very particular about pizza. This pizza is the best around, and I've tried them all. Only Upper Crust for me!!!
06/29/2020 - Karen
I stop in all the time and never once have I been disappointed! the food is great the staff is super friendly and amazing and the prices are not to overdone!
06/29/2020 - Susan
Love the food! Pizza or steak subs are the best thing on the menu by far! all their food is great dont get me wrong but those are just my favorites. Staff is super sweet and will hold conversation with you which is a nice thing
03/23/2020 - Joe
Great Eggplant sub as always, and super friendly service!
04/20/2018 - dianne
I went to the Upper Crust after I got off of work. First time customer, and probably last time customer as well.
Ordered a pizza and a large sub. The pizza was over done, needed more cheese, and I've had more flavorful pizzas before. The sub had more lettuce than meat, and was missing things I asked to be put on it.
The woman at the front desk seemed a little off putting. She was not friendly, looked bothered, and didn't smile... At all. Left a bit disappointed... :(
Meh- I gave it a shot. But, I won't be a regular here or returning for that matter.
07/02/2015 - Dianne
I have been a customer since December 2014 ,pizza has been good til a couple days ago ,when I went home I had 2 burnt pizza's ,I called ,and the woman says we will replace them call the owner tomorrow ,I did call, the owner was not in ,I have been given the run around ,and lied too'' after I paid over 23.00 for pizza ,The manager called me ,and only offered to replace 1 pizza. The least they could have done was to replace the burnt pizza to A loyal Customer so surprised they were so cold ,
I will not be a loyal customer any longer to this business.
08/01/2013 - Kathleen
My husband and I have been to the restaurant 3 times. Each time a mistake was made in at least one of our orders. The 1st time the dressing was left off the chicken and we were told the kitchen was busy and made an error. Ok these things happen. The next was a take out order and my husbands sandwich came on the wrong bread. Ok maybe he was misunderstood when placing the order. Tonight however, we repeated the order to the waitress 3 times and got the wrong order. The waitress was busy talking to the kitchen staff and did not even check to see if everything was ok until I called for her. Even then she came to the edge of the counter instead of the table to ask if all was well. It wasn't until I said no that she came to the table. Again the error was blamed on the kitchen staff. My observation is that less talking and distracting the kitchen staff and more attention paid to the orders and needs of the customers would improve service and satisfaction tremendously. They've had 3 chances. We will not return.
See all restaurants in Tilton
