John & Mary's

Reported as permanently closed. Find something similiar nearby.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

3711 W Main Street Rd
Batavia, NY 14020

Phone: (585) 343-2101

Website

Neighborhood: Batavia

Update Listing

Hours

This restaurant has been reported as permanently closed. Click here if it has reopened.

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

*This restaurant has closed. If this restaurant is open or has reopened, just let us know.

John & Mary's is a Buffalo tradition since 1952. Serving the best subs in Western New York!

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for John & Mary's

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for John & Mary's

Write a Review

  3.7 stars - Based on 31 votes

5 star				10 votes	32%
4 star				10 votes	32%
3 star				5 votes	16%
2 star				3 votes	10%
1 star				3 votes	10%

Top Reviews of John & Mary's

01/12/2024 - MenuPix User

03/26/2022 - T.k.
A used to be double cheese and pepperoni pizza was very cheesy do was Heavy piece was very good lately it's hit or miss

11/17/2021 - MenuPix User
Best Subs in Batavia!

11/13/2020 - Lisa
Best Souvlaki around, hands down! Also have had a few different subs and they were all really good. You can tell the meats are not cheap. Turkey is not like processed Turkey. Keep up the good work!

07/19/2020 - Kathy
I have been happy with everything I’ve tried. My favorite is the chicken ranch hoagie! Super friendly staff as well.

04/24/2020 - Al Bukowski
Got our order wrong again ! According to the menu on the counter we were overcharged ! We will NEVER be back !!!!!

06/03/2019 - Linda
This restaurant has become my favorite stop when I am in Batavia. I have had Subs(cuz I guess that's what they made their name on)Pizza and have recently tried the Souvlaki(which was outstanding) All was really, really good! Never thought I would get great Greek food at a sub and pizza place!

08/06/2018 - Sue
This review is for Leisurewood JandM. The first pizza we ordered was the best we’ve had in a long time and raved about it. I was so looking forward to our next one. What happened? It was so bad we threw half away. It was so undercooked and practically cheeseless. And the cashier didn’t know prices. Also the wings were dry. I feel bad because we were always fans of JandM and we were so excited to have them here.

10/04/2017 - Linda
The food is outstanding. Big John is my favorite, the sausage is really good and the rolls are awesome! I have always found this restaurant to be clean and the staff is very nice. Highly recommend!

08/02/2017 - Cassie
Love John & Mary's. Has been a staple in Buffalo for many years So glad there is one in Batavia now! The Souvlaki is amazing!

06/30/2017 - Bad service!
Horrible food!
Dirty restaurant!!
Service was horrible!
Don't go there,unless you want to be sick 😷

06/25/2017 - Chris
Loved it! Just a good place to eat! Had a Royal sub, so good. Nice toasted roll, and the sausage was delicious! The atmosphere was fun, lots of movie and TV memorabelia.