New York Pizzeria

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

13186 Main St
Cato, NY 13033

Phone: (315) 626-6662

Neighborhood: Cato

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for New York Pizzeria

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for New York Pizzeria

Write a Review

  4.6 stars - Based on 54 votes

#1 out of 6 restaurants in Cato

#1 of 2 Pizza in Cato

5 star				38 votes	70%
4 star				13 votes	24%
3 star				2 votes	4%
2 star				0 votes	0%
1 star				1 votes	2%

Top Reviews of New York Pizzeria

11/18/2024 - Linda Daly
Excellent Food and Service!

05/17/2024 - Jas J.
Really good food!

02/26/2024 - Robert
We found out about the place from a friend. We drive 30 minutes to pick it up. Great pies and wings. Love to support a small business like this one. Keep up all the hard work. We enjoy it every time.

Regards,
RJ

05/08/2023 - MenuPix User
Always Amazing service ! Delicious food !

03/24/2023 - Becky jensen
Amazing

03/21/2021 - MenuPix User
Love their piZza service is great 😃

08/29/2020 - MenuPix User
If you are craving a salad like no other then order the antipasto salad, BEST in the area!!!

05/23/2020 - Sunsi
I've eaten here for te past 20 years, most times the food is amazing. I know I'm going to get a great pizza when it's a weekday and the older lady is working. Sorry, but weekends and the younger crew you takes your chances. Even then though, it's usually pretty good.

04/26/2020 - BJ
Best, and I mean BEST I have ever had in this area ever. I lived in Martville ny, and Oswego ny. Keep up the great service and quality. I’ll be back for sure.

04/26/2020 - BJ
Best, and I mean BEST I have ever had in this area ever. I lived in Martville ny, and Oswego ny. Keep up the great service and quality. I’ll be back for sure.

04/15/2020 - MenuPix User
It has awesome food and the workers are really nice and cooperative!

12/12/2019 - Alyssa
Great staff and great food!

12/02/2019 - Amy
This place has the best pizza around. We drive 30 min. to get their pizza. My husband will not eat it from anywhere else. Wings are great too.

08/04/2018 - Kyle H.
Good pizza but did not look or taste NY style pizza. Maybe they should rename it good pizza.

06/08/2014 - Dave
Poor service. Girl was trying to get someone else to take our order. She wrote it down wrong. Subs had no lettuce and tomatoes, one slice of meat, also asked for NO mayo and got loads of it. Very poor serve, came in at 730pm and was told we could not eat there because they close at 8pm (website says 10pm). Which one is it?

Menu