Nonna Cosentino's Trattoria

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1 Railroad Pl
Geneva, NY 14456

Phone: (315) 789-1638

Website

Neighborhood: Geneva

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

See More Photos

 See All Photos

See All Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Nonna Cosentino's Trattoria

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Nonna Cosentino's Trattoria

Write a Review

  3.5 stars - Based on 41 reviews

#30 out of 110 restaurants in Geneva

#3 of 5 Italian in Geneva

5 star				6 reviews	15%
4 star				14 reviews	34%
3 star				18 reviews	44%
2 star				1 review	2%
1 star				2 reviews	5%

Top Reviews of Nonna Cosentino's Trattoria

07/15/2025 - Top B.
A party of six enjoyed a seamless experience from arriving early for drinks to being promptly seated for dinner, with outstanding service from both the bartenders and servers. The meals, ranging from seafood specials to classic Italian dishes, were flavorful, fresh, and generously portioned, complemented by a variety of salads, breads, and desserts that satisfied everyone at the table. The welcoming atmosphere, attentive staff, and reasonable prices made for a pleasant evening, encouraging a return visit during future trips to the Finger Lakes region.

07/24/2024 - Mike M.
Our group of 6 had a blast at this cozy spot in Geneva. The service was spot-on, the food was delectable, and we left with happy hearts and full bellies. Can't wait to make another reservation and dive back into those generous portions of deliciousness!

02/15/2018 - Michele Turner
We have tried this place in several occasions and each time we give it another chance each time we have an issue, the latest being tonight on Valentines. Dinner reservations were at 6pm for myself, my husband and my 89 year old Mother in law and we never got our meal until 7:05 , asking the waitress what the problem might be she merely stated "I know it will be a few more minutes", the Manager was apparently made aware and cane over and when we asked him he stated "I don't know but will be finding out" never shared with us what it was in the end. By now the night has a mood though the food was ok, we didn't even get a single offer for a free drink and nothing off the bill, greed at its best performance and apparently customer service means nothing so the lack of an offer to make this right will earn them a lot of bad talk amongst anyone we know

02/14/2018 - Michele Turner
We have tried this place in several occasions and each time we give it another chance each time we have an issue, the latest being tonight on Valentines. Dinner reservations were at 6pm for myself, my husband and my 89 year old Mother in law and we never got our meal until 7:05 , asking the waitress what the problem might be she merely stated "I know it will be a few more minutes", the Manager was apparently made aware and cane over and when we asked him he stated "I don't know but will be finding out" never shared with us what it was in the end. By now the night has a mood though the food was ok, we didn't even get a single offer for a free drink and nothing off the bill, greed at its best performance and apparently customer service means nothing so the lack of an offer to make this right will earn them a lot of bad talk amongst anyone we know