Old Mill Restaurant

3.6

19 reviews

#3 out of 31 restaurants in Old Forge

($$$), American, Barbecue, Sandwiches
Hours today: 4:00pm-9:00pm

Add Review

Call

Website

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

2888 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY 13420

Phone: (315) 369-3662

Website

Neighborhood: Old Forge

Update Listing

Bookmark Update Menus Edit Info Read Reviews Write Review

Hours

Open Today:

4:00pm-9:00pm
MondayClosed
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday4:00pm-9:00pm
Thursday4:00pm-9:00pm
Friday4:00pm-9:00pm
Saturday4:00pm-9:00pm
Sunday4:00pm-9:00pm

Update Hours

View the Menu

View Menus

Restaurant Details

Delivery
No delivery

Payment
Credit Cards Accepted

Parking
Yes

Good for Kids
Yes

Attire
Casual

Alcohol

Reservations
No

Cuisines:
American, Barbecue, Sandwiches

Price Point
$$$

WiFi
No

Outdoor Seats
Yes

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

See Menus

Write a Review for Old Mill Restaurant

Reviews for Old Mill Restaurant

Write a Review

3.6 stars - Based on 19 reviews

#3 out of 31 restaurants in Old Forge

#2 of 6 American in Old Forge

5 star	3 reviews	16%
4 star	8 reviews	42%
3 star	6 reviews	32%
2 star	2 reviews	11%
1 star	0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Old Mill Restaurant

07/04/2025 - Carlo H.
I shared wings and had the steak, both cooked well, while enjoying excellent service from Josh and a perfectly balanced Pineapple Jalapeño Margarita from Tim the bartender. The patio offers a beautiful view of the Moose River at sunset, and the overall atmosphere combined with attentive staff made for a very enjoyable dining experience.

Best Menus of Old Forge Best of New York

American Restaurants in Old Forge Barbecue Restaurants in Old Forge Sandwich & Sub Shops in Old Forge

Frankie's ($$)
Italian
Distance: 0.02 miles

Lion King Chinese Restaurant ($$)
Chinese
Distance: 0.10 miles

Lancia Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Distance: 0.11 miles

Benny's Ice Cream ($$)
Desserts
Distance: 0.16 miles

Glazing Saddles Donuts and Eatery ($)
Donuts, Sandwiches, Breakfast
Distance: 0.27 miles

Tony Harper's Pizza and Clam Shack ($$)
American, Pizza

Keyes' Pancake House ($)
Breakfast, American, Brunch

Daikers ($$)
American, Bar Food, Seafood

Tony Harper's Pizza and Clam Shack ($$)
American, Pizza

Up North Wood Fire Bar & Grill (Eagle Bay, NY)

This restaurant offers an incredible dining experience with delicious food and attentive service. Every dish I tried was full of flavor and beautifull... see review

The Front Door Diner (Old Forge, NY)

I enjoyed both breakfast and lunch here, with friendly staff, quick service, and delicious food made from fresh ingredients. The breakfast burrito and... see review

Asteroga Ale House (Herkimer, NY)

I stopped in for lunch while passing through Herkimer and was blown away by the prime rib sandwich and bacon bleu burger—both were incredible and de... see review

Old Mill Restaurant (Old Forge, NY)

I shared wings and had the steak, both cooked well, while enjoying excellent service from Josh and a perfectly balanced Pineapple Jalapeño Margarita ... see review

Northern Lights (Eagle Bay, NY)

The staff was very friendly and attentive, making the experience enjoyable despite a minor issue with a straw cover. The ice cream selection is impres... see review

View Menus

Old Mill Restaurant
Home
New York
Herkimer County
Old Forge

New York Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in New York

United States Restaurant Guide:

AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY

Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:

Most Popular US City Guides:

Old Mill Restaurant

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Old Mill Restaurant

Reviews for Old Mill Restaurant

Top Reviews of Old Mill Restaurant

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Old Mill Restaurant

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Old Mill Restaurant

Reviews for Old Mill Restaurant

Top Reviews of Old Mill Restaurant

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Oops, we can't find your location