Tony's Pizzeria & Deli

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

435 Mohawk St
Herkimer, NY 13350

Phone: (315) 866-4593

Website

Neighborhood: Herkimer

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• 2 Liter
• Kids' Drink *
• Bottled Water
• Order Attention Required
• Gallon Sweet Tea

Hours

Sorry, we don't have hours for this restaurant yet. We'll be updating the hours for this restaurant soon.

Monday: Add Hours
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:
Saturday:
Sunday:

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Tony's Pizzeria & Deli

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Tony's Pizzeria & Deli

Write a Review

  3.9 stars - Based on 45 reviews

#6 out of 36 restaurants in Herkimer

#3 of 7 Pizza in Herkimer

5 star				14 reviews	31%
4 star				22 reviews	49%
3 star				4 reviews	9%
2 star				2 reviews	4%
1 star				3 reviews	7%

Top Reviews of Tony's Pizzeria & Deli

05/27/2024 - Jordan R.
great food

03/25/2021 - Peg
Always friendly service, great delicious food.

12/17/2020 - Sharon
Pizza has gone down hill the past few years. Still willing to try to support local business even tho every time we are disappointed. Not sure how much longer we can stand horrible pizza for the price we pay.

01/12/2020 - Jose Rombardo
Absolutely awesome food, staff was super friendly

12/19/2019 - Little Fallls
Great pizza. Awesome pepperoni! Better than any pizza in little falls...which is 6 miles away...

06/05/2018 - Synthia W
Great pizza! Good subs and other stuff too. Nothing special about the ambiance. Just a a casual restaurant vibe. It's very clean and has a weird football theme going on.

03/28/2018 - Regina Biando
yum, love when they cook my pizza lightly like the old days

11/18/2017 - Valerie
Every week my family orders a large pizza 6lbs of wings.. which is thier special we have always gotten extra cheese and cut in triangle's with our extra blue cheese we pay about 48$ today I order the same exact thing and was told I can't have extra cheese on the pizza then it wouldn't be a special.. I replied with can I just pay for the extra topping the answer was no..I asked how much it was without the extra cheese and was told $45 and some change when I asked how much for the extra cheese it was $52 and some change. $7 for extra cheese. The manager replied with our special is for the wings. Then why does it matter if I ask for extra cheese? How much for a cheese pizza? $14 and some change how much for an extra cheese pizza? $16 and some change! $3 for an extra topping.. but a large special with extra cheese is $7 difference. We will now travel to onieda county for our Tony's pizza!!

06/16/2017 - Anonymous
The sauce on pizza is a main ingredient and Tonys fails. Dont let the flashy toppings fool you. The sauce has a mettalic tinge flavor to it. Very basic can sauce taste. The salads are deploreable. I'm fairly certain my 10 year old daughter could put a better one together. People that like this place are locals that dont get out much.

05/07/2017 - Local diner
The food is good. Service is quick. I could do without the right-wing TV channel while I'm waiting, but other than that, Tony's is fine. Also, they support local high school sports, and there are always great photographs of the kids in action.

04/06/2017 - Mark Alan Conte
I Was visiting the area. I'm a big fan of Tonys. I Went in with an old friend. We both had the best sub, and antipasto. Fantastc, as always. The staff were very sweet, and helpful.


Sincerely,

Mark Alan Conte

06/05/2016 - jojo
the BEST pizza around, we order each time the bacon mushrooms and black olive pizza, its always delicious, loaded with the toppings and the crust is not paper thin, the wings are great too

06/15/2015 - Lisa A.
Best pizza in town! They load the toppings on and the owners/workers are friendly and hard working!

12/12/2014 - jo
their sauce is awful, its bitter, doesnt taste good at all

12/22/2013 - RDM Home for the holidays.
First time, and last 12/22/13.The toppings were just above average but the crust FAILED. It was like a wet slice of bread. It seemed like it was under cooked. We ended up throwing half a large pizza away.