Brooklyn Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

5273 N Route 9w
Newburgh, NY 12550

Phone: (845) 568-3311

Website

Neighborhood: Newburgh

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Brooklyn Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Brooklyn Pizza

Write a Review

  3.7 stars - Based on 18 votes

#74 out of 261 restaurants in Newburgh

#9 of 16 Italian in Newburgh

5 star				5 votes	28%
4 star				6 votes	33%
3 star				5 votes	28%
2 star				0 votes	0%
1 star				2 votes	11%

Top Reviews of Brooklyn Pizza

05/16/2020 - Kathleen
Placed order through GrubHub last night, it was never delivered. I anticipated an easy conversation with whoever was at the store, he tried to place blame first on GrubHub, then got snotty with me. He said he had to check with his boss, which was fine. Boss called me- he’s one of the rudest people I’ve ever dealt with. First, they had no Grub Hub driver, then I placed my order too late, I could find nothing in print that said there was a time cutoff for orders. The money was pending in my husbands bank account. Basically, all we wanted was for our order to be delivered today instead. Owner told me point blank he doesn’t need my $24 and take it up with Grub Hub. I could hear another voice in the background telling him to hang up. Grub Hub was great, they refunded the money and had frankly no idea what was going on because the order had been received at the store. Would it have been so hard for them to have comped that order, especially since it was paid for. I even told the owner that I understand things are tense now, and that I wasn’t trying to give him grief. We were good customers, we ordered on a weekly basis. They’ll never get another order from us.

06/26/2019 - MenuPix User
One of the worst pizzas I have ever tried. I would say to stay away from this place to anybody I know. Piece of cardboard. Wasn't fresh at all and pretty much tasteless. On top of that all of us ended up with upset stomach.
You have been warned!