Pizzeria New York

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

833 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147

Phone: (614) 862-4743

Website

Neighborhood: Pickerington

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Super Hot Deal
• Two large two-topping pizzas and a two-liter soda.
• One For You & One For The Kids (2larges)
• One large four-topping and one large one topping.
• Greek Salad
• Chicken Salad
• Antipasto Salad

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Pizzeria New York

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Pizzeria New York

Write a Review

  4.2 stars - Based on 24 reviews

#7 out of 113 restaurants in Pickerington

#2 of 17 Pizza in Pickerington

5 star				8 reviews	33%
4 star				13 reviews	54%
3 star				3 reviews	13%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Pizzeria New York

05/30/2025 - Amber T.
The pizza here captures the authentic New York style with a perfectly balanced crust that bends just right, fresh vegetables, and well-seasoned meats, making each bite a flavorful experience that contrasts sharply with the usual thin, square-cut pizzas around town. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, especially the warm greeting from the owner's son who shared the family's story, made enjoying the Paps Special even more memorable-it's a culinary trip worth making again and again.

01/27/2025 - Thomas J.
The pizza was incredibly delicious, with fresh vegetables and perfectly seasoned meat on a buttery textured crust. The friendly service and warm atmosphere made the dining experience even more enjoyable, and I can't wait to go back and try more of their offerings. This pizza place truly captures the essence of a New York-style pie, and I'm grateful to have found a taste of home in Pickerington.

06/27/2024 - Megan M.
great food and service

Menu