Reviews for Casey's Pizza & Sub Shop

08/31/2025 - Andrew P.
The potato soup here is seriously comforting, and their cinnamon breadsticks are the perfect sweet finish after pizza. The staff, especially Emma and the bartenders, are super friendly and attentive, making every visit enjoyable even when it's busy. Whether dining in with the lively atmosphere or grabbing takeout, the food-from the Far-East Pizza to the Philly cheesesteak-is always fresh, flavorful, and satisfying.

08/07/2010 - RedRiverGreen
GREAT soups!!!

04/30/2010 - RedWingsRock
Best pizza I've ever had! Can't believe the chains are still in business since Casey's opened up. You'll never have to order double cheese - unlike the chains who charge for double cheese and rarely put it on the pizza.

Soups and sandwiches are delicious! The breadsticks are awesome too!

Good prices for great food - we eat here weekly.

06/01/2009 - Dawn
Simply put: Priced way to high and poor quality pizza. Pizza Sauce has zero flavor, the cheese is like rubber and a average pizza dough at best. I was not pleased at all.

01/13/2009 - MenuPix User
It is definitely a great place to head out and eat. Although the prices are a tad high, you are given exceptionally quick service to make up for it.

08/29/2008 - nick
Great food, place order at counter and they bring it to your table, no wait staff. Prices are a little high but if you are in the Downtown area they deliver free with a +$10.00 order.