Reviews for Village Inn

10/21/2021 - MenuPix User
Ordered a VI Salad with Balsamic dressing - requested extra dressing
Ordered mini perch with extra tartar sauce

Received salad with raspberry vinaigrette dressings x 2
fish with one tartar sauce.
No silverware

What's going on VI?

05/13/2010 - suttonsbay01
We have recently been to the Village Inn and are happy to see the changes that have taken place in the last year. The food is good... the staff is friendly... and it has become our favorite spot to eat and its great for drink in their tavern.

11/06/2008 - chice67
This Inn used to be great. It isn't any more. We just went there for our wedding anniversary. They have a Lobster special. 1 1/2 lb. lobster dinner for $29.95. Kind of steep for us, so my parents got us a gift certificate. The small dinner salad was descent which was accompanied by the smallest dinner rolls I have ever seen. Then we get our entree. It looked great. It came with a stalk of broccoli that had been cooked until it was much at the touch of a fork. The baked potato could easily have been made a day or two earlier and just warmed up. I could have lived with all of that, but the lobster. It was the absolute worse I have ever had. I didn't know lobster could be so chewy and rubbery that it can't be chewed up. I actually had to spit most of the tail out because it chewed like gum. I mentioned it to the waitress and she just laughed a dumb laugh and didn't respond at all. When she came back again to ask if we wanted dessert, I told her very bluntly that it was the worse lobster we had ever had and it was horribly chewy. She didn't say a word. She just left and came back with the check. Yes, the check was for the whole amount. No apology, no discounted price, nothing at all. I still can't believe how bad it was. We both left and went to get something to eat at my Moms.
That is absolutely no way to run a business. They should never have charged us anything, and at the very least, we should have been apologized to. I knew it wouldn't be the same without Eddie, but I never expected it to get this bad.
This experience was a minus 5 stars