Reviews for The Old Firehall Restaurant

04/25/2025 - Josie B.
The food was freshly prepared, and we ordered four different sandwiches, all of which were satisfying, complemented by perfectly seasoned, crispy fries. The service was attentive and friendly, and the atmosphere had a charming vintage feel that added to our enjoyable experience.

05/22/2024 - Gloria J.
its the best

03/01/2023 - MenuPix User
Mar2023: I had high hopes for this tiny restaurant based on the reviews, especially the French Onion Soup, which had raves online.

My wife and I shared a light meal: French Onion Soup, Calimari, and Roasted Veggie Salad.

The Veggie Salad was the standout, a 9/10; tasty and a good sized portion. We'd order this again in a heartbeat.

The grilled Calimari was very tasty, but the value wasn't there. For $17 I expected twice the quantity, and unfortunately we wouldn't order it again.

The raved-about French Onion Soup was the standout failure; a 3/10 would be generous. It's not my job to figure what went wrong in the kitchen, but I suspect the pot of broth wasn't stirred before being ladled into the bowl. The finished product looked great, but the soup was 75% oil, had very few onions, and tasted awful. We sent it back after a couple of spoonfuls, and it was appropriately taken off the bill.
Sadly, we won't be running back to The Old Firehall any time soon. Our first impressions obviously stung.

05/12/2015 - jessie1990
Pretty bad food. Salads are bland and chicken was dry. We will not be going back, overpriced and not tasty.

04/04/2013 - Jim Kowolski
Visited here on a recommendation. Food was great, everything was prepared perfectly and the service was great. I would highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.