Reviews for The Old Firehall Restaurant

03/10/2024 - MenuPix User

02/13/2024 - MenuPix User

03/01/2023 - MenuPix User
Mar2023: I had high hopes for this tiny restaurant based on the reviews, especially the French Onion Soup, which had raves online.

My wife and I shared a light meal: French Onion Soup, Calimari, and Roasted Veggie Salad.

The Veggie Salad was the standout, a 9/10; tasty and a good sized portion. We'd order this again in a heartbeat.

The grilled Calimari was very tasty, but the value wasn't there. For $17 I expected twice the quantity, and unfortunately we wouldn't order it again.

The raved-about French Onion Soup was the standout failure; a 3/10 would be generous. It's not my job to figure what went wrong in the kitchen, but I suspect the pot of broth wasn't stirred before being ladled into the bowl. The finished product looked great, but the soup was 75% oil, had very few onions, and tasted awful. We sent it back after a couple of spoonfuls, and it was appropriately taken off the bill.
Sadly, we won't be running back to The Old Firehall any time soon. Our first impressions obviously stung.

05/12/2015 - jessie1990
Pretty bad food. Salads are bland and chicken was dry. We will not be going back, overpriced and not tasty.

04/04/2013 - Jim Kowolski
Visited here on a recommendation. Food was great, everything was prepared perfectly and the service was great. I would highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.