Reviews for Mr. J's Pizza Etc

08/24/2025 - Jacob R.
The pizza from Mr. J's has had a meaningful impact on my life, bringing joy and a renewed sense of purpose through its fresh ingredients, flavorful toppings, and unique offerings like panzerotti. Despite the modest appearance and occasional wait times, the friendly service and delicious food make it a favorite choice that consistently exceeds expectations.

02/12/2025 - Kristina S.
Mr. J's Pizza has transformed my dining experience, providing not only delicious pizza but also a sense of joy that has positively impacted my life. Despite its unassuming exterior, the friendly service and amazing flavors have made it my go-to choice for pizza on the island.

04/22/2024 - Your M.
Excellent food and Great service.

10/29/2021 - Lotten
Mr J has, for many years, custom made his JRock salad for me 😊 Substituting chicken for shrimp and omitting celery. It's the best salad in our valley, and cones with mouth watering garlic bread!

01/25/2021 - Donna
Years of great food and good service. Thank you Mr J❣️. You really do rock!!

02/24/2013 - Barry
By far the best pizza in town! I've purchased pizza several times over a few months at Mr. J's and haven't been disappointed yet. Very reasonably priced too.