Reviews for Smitty's Tavern

06/18/2025 - Mark Bellamy
Smitty's is a very friendly neighborhood bar & tavern in New Holland, Ohio. We are a small Village located on the border of Pickaway County & Fayette County. Smitty's did a 50/50 drawing for our upcoming 'COPS & KIDS Fishing' event to be held at the Village Park & Pond July 19th. Raised a nice chunk of change for the kids. Shout out & THANKS to Sabrina Colburn! What a nice lady. Smitty's is an integral part of our small community & they put on fundraisers for charity all the time. GREAT folks!!! Recommended AAA+++

07/24/2024 - Mo N.
Initially skeptical about the unusual scene of people exploring the walls and ceiling, but it turned out to be a fun Easter egg hunt. The friendly atmosphere and hardworking bartenders made me look forward to returning.

04/27/2024 - Just B.
Grand!

04/21/2019 - Joseph William Bryan
Just wanted to show sympathy for my last comment about not adding a few words in my statement. I forgot to say build a hotel in New Holland for people to succumb to in order for collaboration to exist in an orderly fashion.

04/12/2019 - Joseph William Bryan
Just wanted to complement the staff and the new management that has now implemented new industrial change inside the tavern. The amazing amount of people that join and go to the tavern or surmountable. I am planning on going to the tavern on May 25 when Jack Middleton is there to perform for the amazing crowd! Miller Lite Bette R' Us"¼ï¸â‰ï¸ No that means there better "LET IT BE" in stock inventory logistically for distribution on tab or we better a new #HOTTHOTEL"¼ï¸