Reviews for Agatucci's Restaurant

06/10/2025 - Sam-I-Am
BEST Pizza anywhere !

4th Generation Family Owned

Since 1958, been going here

09/02/2024 - Astrid S.
This pizza joint is a must-try for any pizza aficionado. The classic tavern-style thin crust, rich sauce, and retro vibe make it a standout choice for a delicious meal. With its longstanding history and dedicated following, this place truly delivers on quality and taste.

05/05/2024 - Amina A.
Truly the best

06/12/2023 - MenuPix User
Had family in from Texas this past Friday, and as always wanted Aggies pizza. We had a party of over 20 people, so instead of coming to restaurant, decided to order and eat at home. Called on Thursday to give a heads up of large order, and was told " no problem ". My daughter and niece went to pick up order on Friday, and were totally disgusted with the way they were treated. Who ever was working in the kitchen was cussing and using foul language with the size of the order. We spent approx $300 dollars, and will think twice before doing any more business with them.

06/12/2023 - MenuPix User
Had family in from Texas this past Friday, and as always wanted Aggies pizza. We had a party of over 20 people, so instead of coming to restaurant, decided to order and eat at home. Called on Thursday to give a heads up of large order, and was told " no problem ". My daughter and niece went to pick up order on Friday, and were totally disgusted with the way they were treated. Who ever was working in the kitchen was cussing and using foul language with the size of the order. We spent approx $300 dollars, and will think twice before doing any more business with them.

01/24/2023 - Pizza lover
Your food is crap !

05/15/2022 - Carol
I lived in Peoria for 30 years. This pizza place was busy from opening to closing every day. Bradley university students come back to Peoria just to eat this pizza. I spent every Mother's Day there eating pizza with the kids. The Bradley baseball players loved it too

12/17/2021 - Ryan
One star this place should be closed .

06/17/2021 - Tom Bishop
I would take my family here and always enjoyed . Now Megan left me I can't even drive by without crying . Thank you !

06/02/2021 - Mike
Lost me after 40 years pizza went down hill fast

05/26/2021 - Shoe taste better
Pizza has been terrible the last 20 years . Kids don't have clue running it . Was good pizza in 1920 when people would eat a shoe .

05/26/2021 - Pizza lover
I love pizza and can't say I've had many bad ones . But this place will go down in history as worst pizza I've ever had . Crust burnt sauce little toppings from a can make your own save money . Or in desperate times go frozen before going here .

05/23/2021 - Jackie Davis
The food is all from a can nothing fresh ! Try a tombstone frozen pizza it's better then this place . Also clean up or close it's a total dump and no parking !!!

05/12/2021 - Johnson
You people and your dirty pizza joint . Give it up terrible food !

05/11/2021 - No taste
Garbage that's what I call your pizza sir ! Spend your money anywhere but this dump .

05/11/2021 - Jack
Worst pizza ever total waste of money won't be back

05/10/2021 - Jack
Good people can't say the same for food . Sorry it's just not good . Gave it three try's and last time we didn't pay but had to eat else where .