Reviews for Olde Tyme Steakhaus

04/01/2021 - Terre
Very good food. Cooked exactly the way it was ordered. Best steakhouse in the area!

04/07/2018 - Stan
We took our preacher and his wife to the Steakhause for dinner on a Sat night around 6 pm. The parking lot was packed and we had to park along the street. As we entered we were greeted by the OWNER Penny. Yes the owner was working SAt night. We told her we was expecting 2 more and our name. We were seated very quickly and within 5 minutes the preacher and his wife were escorted right to our table!!!!!!! He was impressed they remembered exactly who we were and where. I ordered a New York Strip and it was for sure a choice or better and a large thin cut so it was cooked perfectly without grissle and no aftertaste you get with "tenderized"meat. Everything was great for all 4 of us. They have more seating than parking so do not worry about waiting 30 minutes to get in and be seated. We have been back several times eith no issues and a polite staff that never 'rushes' you to get the table. Best steaks in Olney bay far and worth a 20-30 min drive!!!

01/02/2016 - Never Again
The steaks were over-cooked, tough and served to us warm (not hot). The "grilled shrimp" was cocktail shrimp skewed with some spiced sprinkled on top. It was very obviously not grilled. Their baked potatoes are served with prepackaged margarine and sour cream (paper peel off lid) much like you would find at a diner, not a steakhouse. The waitress did not return to our table until approximately 20 minutes later. Our bill was approximately $70 for 3 adult meals and 1 kids meal (one soda/no alcohol). The quality of food definitely was not worth the price.