Reviews for Benny's Pizza

04/17/2024 - Ella V.
Magic

02/09/2024 - MenuPix User

01/15/2023 - MenuPix User
Great food and friendly staff

10/22/2018 - Ricardo
This place is awesome way better experience from last pizza in the area we tried. Pizza and sub makers at there finest quality food made by a quality establishment don’t waist your time with any other pizza close to here they can’t touch Benny’s!!

02/10/2016 - Jeff C.
Best pizza around we love it especially the Banker's Special. Tastes super even when cold not many pizzas can claim that. Why fool with Pizza Rut when we have Benny's? Happy Joe's not bad but way too expensive give us Benny's anyday!

01/15/2016 - Bert Catlin
I'm from New York, the original Pizza Palace of America, and I discovered Benny's Pizza even before I finally relocated to Milan - Benny's makes the VERY BEST pizza in the area - (outside of my own home-made New York Style pizza). We Love it and buy it there regularly.

04/27/2014 - Jon
Best pizza and amazing service! Even though they are very busy at times (understandable with the quality of food) I have never had a cold or disappointing meal from here. Three thumbs up!

06/16/2011 - karolyn
great food!!!!!!

12/05/2009 - Kory D
By far best Pizza I've ever eaten. Will recommend to anyone and every one.