Reviews for Coney McKane's American Eatery

05/29/2024 - Rocky H.
Great food and service.

06/30/2022 - Marge Inman
You make the food taste so good I took some home.

06/20/2020 - Blake
Coney McKanes = 💩💩💩
Just had one of the WORST dining experiences I've had in recent memory. Wife and I had decided to get out of the house and take the boys out for dinner. We went downtown to Coney McKanes and it's safe to say that we will never be returning.

-Both my wife's order and my own were the wrong items
-Forgot our son's order completely
-Very rude server ... not sure if he got embarrassed about messing up the orders and then just doubled-down on making sure it was going to be a bad experience for us or maybe he was just having a bad day 🤷‍

Seriously can't get over how rude and passive-aggressive the server got

05/12/2020 - Sharon
This is my favorite restaurant in D-town! I love it. Excellent food and friendly staff.

04/05/2020 - MenuPix User
Excellent service and food! Best desserts in town and amazing friendly staff! Love the variety of menu choices and the family friendly environment.
Not sure how someone left a negative review on 3/27/20 stating the staff is rude and inconsiderate since the dining area has been closed due to Covid-19?? Also, please know that some of the negative reviews are from a disgruntled DoorDash employee who made false claims against the establishment for attention and failed miserably. This person even recruited friends and family from out of state who have never stepped foot inside the restaurant to post bad reviews. Try this restaurant for yourself and see there’s a reason why they’re so highly regarded.

03/27/2020 - MenuPix User
I have found the staff to be rude and inconsiderate. If you are not a regular at the restaurant, the service staff tends to keep talking with their regular customers and unless you ask them to take your order, you are ignored

02/11/2020 - MenuPix User
The food is great, but it is the rudest place to go to in Decatur! Most of the daytime waitress are rude or just not friendly at all. I would rather eat somewhere with maybe not as good so as not to have to put up with them! And trying to place an order on the phone is a joke! They leave you on the phone for a long time then eventually hang up with no response!