Reviews for Toasted Owl Tavern

06/25/2025 - Leah C.
Finding good food options after regular hours is such a relief, and this kitchen offshoot of Fitzwilly's hits the mark with its late closing time and friendly vibe. Jordan's service always brightens my visits, and the mozzarella and boneless tenders left me genuinely impressed-seriously some of the best I've ever tasted. Sitting at the bar with a delicious beer and enjoying the Vermont burger topped with maple aioli and cheddar made for a memorable meal, and I'm already looking forward to trying their mac and cheese night next time.

06/11/2024 - Genny M.
Top of the World

05/29/2024 - Ashley L.
After a late night, it's a relief to find a great dining option open until 10:30 pm like this kitchen connected to Fitzwilly's. Jordan, our server, always greets us with a smile and provides exceptional service. The mozzarella sticks here are absolutely delicious and a must-try.