Reviews for Barnaby's

07/17/2024 - Tracy Shaw
The sandwiches they gave us for take out, felt like they were a day or 2 old.. The meat wasn't rotten or anything, but you could tell these spent time in the fridge.

05/26/2024 - Jan Haynes
Officially"¦.. South Bend's worst pizza..

Overcooked, not enough cheese or toppings..

Avoid at all costs..

05/09/2024 - Amy Kay
👎👎

04/12/2024 - Vera Sadlowski
Horrible "cardboard" pizza!!

12/10/2023 - Chris and Jody Tellier
We stopped here after a Notre Dame game. The only thing worse than the Irish losing was eating this pizza! It was overcooked and skimped on toppings.

11/26/2023 - Lori Higgs
The pizza was really second rate. I would have been better off going to Meijer and getting the 2 for $8 special on 'Tombstone' pizzas.

08/25/2023 - Alicia F.
Best pizza in town??
I think not.

08/21/2023 - Jeffrey Adams
Lousy pizza.👎👎👎

07/13/2023 - Mike Sterken
The review below said the pizza tasted like cardboard. They weren't wrong. It was awful.
Don't waste your money on this place.

05/24/2023 - Bob Meiler
Terrible food!!🤮

04/21/2023 - Nick Geiger
Awful food"¦.🤮

04/11/2023 - Mike Sweeney
Pizza wasn't very impressive. Had the consistency of cardboard.

04/07/2023 - Chris Roggow
Was unimpressed with the pizza (the story I was told was that it was "epic"). The service was very poor also.
I will try one of the other South Bend pizza places the next time we venture out.

02/08/2023 - Ralf Zapke
This has got to be the worst pizza place in town"¦ not only for quality, but for service.

01/22/2023 - Benjamin O.
The pizza was very mediocre. Tasted like it was under a heat lamp for a long time. Not very impressed.

11/28/2022 - Cynthia Dittoe
Love their pizza and the sandwiches are wonderful too!

09/14/2022 - L Murphy
Pizza was "meh""¦.

04/05/2022 - Karrie Kaltenback
Best pizza in town"¦. If this was the only pizza place IN TOWN!
Not coming here again.

03/24/2022 - Alan Herrington
Pizza was overcooked

03/12/2022 - Samantha U.
Bad service

02/28/2022 - Sarah Fraser
I wasn't very impressed with the pizza here. The reviews seem to be a mixed bag. My pizza tasted stale and didn't look fresh. Heat lamp too long perhaps?

01/16/2022 - MenuPix User
Best pizza in town - take home 1/2 baked and finish when you're ready

01/04/2022 - Richard Lynch
Pizza wasn't very good. I won't be returning.

12/31/2021 - Mike Stolten
Service wasn't very fast or friendly. First time here and not impressed enough to return.

12/15/2021 - Mike Valone
Pizza was mediocre . Crust was overdone and they were a little cheap on the cheese..

12/07/2021 - Mellonie Brown
Pizza toppings were somewhat scant, and I ordered the Special 2. A pizza place will not get good "marks" if they cheap out on ingredients.
Be more generous and I might consider returning.

11/19/2021 - MenuPix User
Barnabys Pizza has been around for many years. And if it is not the best pizza in Michiana, it is way
ahead of whatever is in 2nd place. It is my familys' go to pizza and we take all of our out of town
friends there to marvel at the great taste.

10/26/2021 - Brent Murphy
Pizza was horrible. Tasted like cardboard"¦

01/04/2020 - Bob heñderson
Good , Great,John Spagnola is wounder!!!