Reviews for Michael's Pastry Shop

03/15/2025 - Virginia A.
As a Brooklyn native, I finally visited Michael's Pastry Shop, which is affiliated with the popular Michael's of Brooklyn restaurant located just across the street. The welcoming staff and reasonable prices complemented the wide array of offerings, including Italian cookies, pastries, and homemade sauces, creating an inviting atmosphere reminiscent of traditional bakeries. While the treats I sampled were delicious, I found them a bit too sweet for my taste; however, the quality and freshness of the baked goods, along with the friendly service, will certainly entice me to return.

05/20/2024 - Wendy H.
absolutely the BEST!!

06/13/2023 - MenuPix User
I usually get their cupcake which are absolutely delicious but I ordered a cake and it was even more delicious than I expected!! 1000000/10

06/04/2023 - Maureen P
I've been going to Micheals Bakery for about 20 years. It's always perfect. Recently I ordered a custom cake for a celebration. I showed a picture, and Michael's bakers created a master piece. The cake was absolutely beautiful, perfect, delicious and exactly like the picture. Everyone was complimenting on how pretty and delicious

12/13/2022 - MenuPix User
The best ❣️❣️

09/07/2021 - June
I ordered cookies and they were delicious. Packing was perfect and cookies were delivered in perfect condition

12/17/2020 - Jill sallustio
Always ready to help. Workers are always very nice.

03/29/2020 - Rebecca
Always fresh, delicious and friendly staff!