Reviews for Carlos O'Kelly's Mexican Cafe

07/28/2025 - Gabriel C.
I had some solid Tex-Mex food on the east side of town with a sporty southwest vibe that made for a perfect pre-game lunch. The birria tacos were delicious, and the cheesy mashed potatoes were a great side, while the service was friendly and attentive even though there was a slight wait for my freshly brewed iced tea. Prices were reasonable, the atmosphere was clean and welcoming, and I'm already looking forward to coming back soon.

08/30/2024 - Ian Y.
The Tex Mex cuisine at this eatery is solid, located on the east side of town. It's a great choice for a pre-game lunch on a Saturday, especially if you're looking for gluten-free options in Manhattan. The service was friendly, although our server seemed a bit shy, and there was a slight delay in receiving my iced tea, but it was freshly brewed which I appreciated.