Reviews for Puffy's Steak & Ice House

01/04/2022 - MenuPix User
My husband and I went for our anniversary and the food and service was wonderful

02/21/2013 - Courtney D.
Honestly I was very disappointed. We drove all the way from Topeka to eat there. For one there was no Bar that night. 2 it took an hour to be seated when there was hardly anyone in the place. 4 when we finally got seated it took a while for the waitress to even come. Then when we ordered our steaks (rare) we got the medium well. WE sent them back.. and they came back the same. I sent mine back and just told them to take it off our ticket. My boyfriend sucked it up and at his well done steak (instead of rare). Then the part of the evening that baffled me was that they still wanted to charge us for my STEAK! that i didn't eat or take a bite of!!!!! We refused and then they said "well you have to pay for your salad and potato.." Uh no I refused that too.. well the potato.. I didn't eat any of my potato.... but i paid for the salad. Anyway I will never eat there again.