Reviews for El Maguey

05/17/2025 - Ross Y.
The food here is consistently delicious, with favorites like the Cadillac margaritas and shrimp fajitas always impressing. Despite some minor service issues, the vibrant atmosphere and quick meal preparation make it a go-to for tasty Mexican cuisine.

11/23/2024 - Kenneth D.
The food at this Mexican restaurant is absolutely delicious, from the flavorful fajitas to the mouthwatering chimichangas. Despite the restaurant's 3-star rating, the service is fast, the portions are generous, and the vibrant atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for tasty Tex-Mex cuisine.

02/19/2024 - Not Customers Any More- PEDRO
We've spent $200 every week for the last 10 years with this El Maguey and It all came to an END with PEDRO's unprofessional behavior tonight. We visit this place three times every week and for whatever reason, the last time we were there, PEDRO refused to wait on our table, even when Maria said something to him. Tonight, PEDRO started banging chairs around and cleaning perfectly CLEAN chairs next to our table. He was so LOUD that I finally asked him to go somewhere else. PEDRO refused! After Fernando asked why we didn't finish our dinner, we advised him that PEDRO ruined our dinner by causing a peace disturbance right next to our table. We realize that PEDRO has some sort of issue with us, so we'll take our business to another restaurant. Goodbye to Benjamin, Fernando, Maria, Maria, Julian, Jesus (Chuey) and staff. We've loved you guys since 2014, but PEDRO is the reason that El Maguey in St. Peters will lose $2400 every year because PEDRO is an irritating, unfriendly, annoying POS. You guys should send him back to Guadalajara so he can be where he wants to be. Goodbye!