Reviews for Pagliai's Pizza

05/10/2025 - Anthony F.
For decades, this restaurant has been the go-to destination for pizza lovers in Mankato, and I can see why after my few visits. The flavors are authentic, the service is friendly, and the atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, making it a spot worth returning to.

01/16/2025 - Allison V.
This pizzeria has been a staple in Mankato for years, known for its authentic flavors and generous toppings. Whenever I'm passing through, I make sure to stop by and savor their delicious hand-tossed pizzas, each bite filled with cheesy goodness.

06/26/2024 - Mary Z.
Best meal out

05/18/2023 - Susan
Fresh, tasty food. Very courteous staff that pays attention to detail. Love their pizza and everything, salads, soups, wings and sandwiches.

08/22/2022 - MenuPix User
Two times in a row -pizza orders lost -will not be back!

08/22/2022 - MenuPix User
Two times there sat forever waiting for pizza finally found out both times the pizza was lost and we're just making-no thank you, won't be back!

06/09/2021 - Jyme Neilsen
Excellent Pizza & French Dip sandwichs !!!
You wouldn't be disappointed!!!

06/12/2020 - Jyme Neilsen
Awesome Pizza!!! 🍕
Good food too!!!

04/24/2020 - Jackie B
Excellent pizza! Delicious homemade crust & loaded with toppings.

03/20/2020 - MenuPix User
foods delicious & the staff is awesome

06/17/2016 - Pamela
Best pizza Ever !!! Wish they would open one in Madisonville,Ky

01/24/2012 - Jessica
All other pizza seems yuck compared to this. It is seriously the best I have ever eaten. The wings, homemade ranch and wings are all incredible! Of course, all the cheese and bread isn't great for a diet, but, wow, it's good!

04/22/2009 - Michele Hunter
Salads are wonderful, freshly made, pizzas are jaw dropping good, and desserts are even better. Cheesecake is the best, well heck there all good!

10/25/2008 - kelley egbert
best pizza i've ever had. salads are great too.