Reviews for Angelinas Eatery

05/06/2025 - Christopher L.
The family running this restaurant is incredibly welcoming, and the baked and stuffed shrimp make for a perfect appetizer. The pizza is some of the best I've had, complemented by a fantastic selection of craft beers and a cozy atmosphere that's ideal for a night out with friends or family.

08/07/2024 - Samara N.
The family that runs this eatery is wonderful. Starting with the baked and stuffed shrimp is a tasty way to begin your meal. Their Antipasto salad is filling and won't slow you down - make sure to end the meal with an Old Fashioned made by George Selleke, he's a master at it. Cheers!

06/11/2024 - Candy W.
Taste bud party

08/10/2017 - Nancy
Stopped at Angelina's after not going there for quite some time. We ordered pizza and were very pleasantly surprised! It was excellent...one of the best we've had in a while. We loved how the restaurant is decorated & the servers were very friendly & efficient. One of the girls showed us the other part where they are doing renovations & hoping to start brewery in there...we were definitely impressed & hope that they are successful in their future endeavors. We will definitely plan to stop in there again soon!!

09/07/2016 - Patrick T
Came from Chicago and wasn't disappointed. Good pizza and nice friendly staff in a nice small town. Definitely some of the best pizza I've had in the state.

10/20/2015 - Jim
I am from Chicago and this was absolutely one of the finest pizzas I have ever had, What a hidden gem, they need to move somewhere more populated, Like Chicago!!! My daughters Calzone was to die for, and my wife's Alfredo Dinner was fresh, and delicious. Don't pass this place up.

03/28/2015 - Anonymous
Food was good but service took forever ordered a salad and a calzone only ones in the restaurant took an hour.