Reviews for Settlement

06/13/2025 - Basil W.
Walking into this cozy, unpretentious spot just outside Green Bay feels like stepping into a warm gathering of familiar faces and friendly chatter. The generous portions of crispy, flaky haddock and massive baskets of fries satisfy every craving, while the strong old fashioneds add a perfect touch of comfort to the experience. Though the space is small and cash-only, the genuine hospitality and timeless charm make every visit feel like coming home.

09/12/2024 - Taylor G.
Looking for a place to chow down where the staff treats you like family and the fish fry is the best in town? Swing by The Settlement on a Friday for their epic fish fry or hit them up on Tuesdays for some authentic Mexican grub. Trust me, the atmosphere is welcoming, the portions are huge, and the prices are a steal - it's like stumbling upon a hidden treasure in the heart of Green Bay!

05/03/2024 - Cathie R.
Divine

09/30/2016 - Mary
The Settlement is a great place for great food. We love all their food, but especially love the Friday night Haddock. We always order the double so we can have leftovers for days, the portions are huge, the prices are very reasonable. You will have to be prepared to wait, because they are always busy, but they have excellent drink prices as well. Always have friendly employees as well. We live in Pulaski and drive there often with no hesitation.