Reviews for Petrillo's

12/28/2023 - MenuPix User

12/02/2016 - Chari cebula
We have been to the restaurant that several times in the past with a crowd. And the food was always great. BUT the last two times the food was under cooked, or cold, the spinage dip was more mayo then anything else. And as for the service it was a 3 on a scale of 1 to 10.I don't think we will go back. To bad it has gone down hill to the point where you used to had to wait up to 20 minutes 4 a table, and now even on a Friday night 90% of tables were empty.

05/30/2016 - Brad
Wonderful staff and great food. Could eat here every night.

05/30/2016 - Brad
Wonderful staff and great food. Could eat here every night.

04/28/2011 - Beth
Whether I'm driving (12 hours from Virginia) or flying to Freeport, it's my first stop! Have a hard time deciding ......the special of the night or pizza!! Can't go wrong with either one!!!

08/03/2010 - chris
Food so good I almost cried. I had mussels and crispy bacon with pasta, and it was just superb. Unpretentious attitude and great staff. The owner and chef looks like an ex-con who went on to become a triathlete, mixed martial arts expert, and, most demonstrably, culinary genius. I would move to Freeport just to be able to eat here all the time.

11/01/2009 - Jimbo
Great pizza!!