Reviews for Smiley's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

01/02/2025 - Kathi W.
The dark chocolate raspberry ice cream at Smiley's is simply divine, with its rich homemade flavor and creamy texture. I also enjoyed the vanilla ice cream, despite the presence of some small crystals, as it was delicious. The peanut butter ice cream, a rarity these days, stood out as the best I've ever had, making it a true indulgence. The friendly service and generous portion sizes of the cones and sundaes at Smiley's ensure a satisfying experience for any ice cream lover.

06/19/2021 - MenuPix User
The best ice cream ANYWHERE!! The sundaes are delicious, especially maple walnut, but even just having a cone is like a taste of heaven-so creamy, so good. My family has been going to Smiley's for almost 50 years, and it is as great as ever!!

07/10/2020 - MenuPix User
Fond memories of going to Smiley's on a summer evening. Always a line and for good reason! Great Ice Cream. Best Sundaes around (the secret? French Vanilla instead of regular and REAL homemade hot fudge sauce). Pistachio is my favorite, but it is ALL good!

03/16/2010 - Guess
YUM!! I WISH IT WAS OPEN NOW! I WANT TO GO THERE AND GET AWAY FROM MY MOTHER! SHE IS BEING ANNOYING

07/19/2009 - Geoffrey Garrett
Maine is loaded with Ice Cream parlors, small and large.
I've eaten at Smiley's in Winslow, ME since 1983 and visit whenever I'm near. My wife prefers the Peanut Butter flavor and I cannot decide on a favorite. The service is top notch and the ice cream is always great.