Reviews for Preshy's Restaurant

02/25/2024 - Maggie
We found Preshy’s to be delightful! The food was excellent very authentic Northern Italian, and extremely reasonable. The atmosphere is very casual laid-back no-frills, but clean and comfortable. The owner Roberto is delightful! We can highly recommend this restaurant.

05/22/2020 - Laurie C
We ordered from here last night. Veal Piccata and Shrimp Parmigiana. Delicious and the owner could not have been nicer. We will be heading back soon.

05/14/2020 - MenuPix User
We love the food and service at Preshy's. We look forward to dining there again soon! Roberto is always gracious and welcoming. The food is delicious and reasonably priced.

05/09/2020 - Amy
Wonderful italian food at low prices.... normal portions.

02/15/2020 - MenuPix User
Always great food

12/09/2019 - Donna
Good old fashioned Italian cooking. Great prices. They don't rush you out, which I enjoy when eating out. Have brought several friends here over the past year and we all enjoy it.

04/04/2019 - MenuPix User
all I can say is RUDE !!!!!!

06/03/2015 - Pat
Fantastic Chicken Marsala. Pure Italian. I have found my new favorite place to have a delicious meal.

12/29/2013 - Lyndee Demeo
LONG LIVE PRESHY'S!
Do not eat here if you're a glutinous diva - or you need food your way, not the right way!
DO EAT HERE if you care more about fine food, made-to-order with fresh ingredients - served in civilized portions at fantastically low prices! Roberto, the crotchety old Italian owner, is very matter-of-fact and temperamental (most artists are). It's fun to humor the mad genius and if you respect his menu you will find Roberto to be both kind and generous. I have been a customer for several years and say it is the most consistently delicious food at the Beach - and the prices are ridiculously low (more proof of his craziness). The creamy lasagna w/ homemade noodles - gnocchi, little clouds of basil flaked whipped potatoes swimming in garden-fresh marinara - grilled Portabella salad $4.95 - and Arabiatta only "iffa-you-likey-really-hotta". If you need to be a glutton - order two $8-$10 entrees - you will still be paying less than most restaurants charge for one! I often see the owners of several of the finest (& most expensive) restaurants dining there - and they get the same "Roberto charm" but come back for more. I dread the day he get's tired of the complainers and gives the biz up - no one will ever replace his beautiful wife's cooking (she's the chef, by the way). So Prima Donnas stay away - but if you want a down home delicious experience that's a bargain --- go to Preshy's and tell Roberto "yes Sir - as you suggest it will be just fine"