Reviews for Jimmy's Italian Tavern

07/28/2011 - Peter Reilly
Dinner,Drinks,
and Crossed Keys Wedding after-party.

The Food was fantastic all weekend.
The service was great even into the wee hours.
Our crowd was handled like family, even as we spilled over into the bar, to hear the live music.
Thank you,for helping to make our nearby wedding at the Crossed Keys,a Success.
Tara and Pete

02/24/2011 - Dr. Katzenberg
If I could give this place no stars I would. The food was terrible, the service was terrible and despite having made a reservation I still didn't get a table for the time I wanted. I had taken my mother to Jimmy's Italian Tavern for her 83rd birthday. I had a party of 6 people and a reservation for 6:30pm. I arrived a bit early and let who I assume to be the owner know that I was here and I would wait for my party at the bar. He did inform me that it would be a couple of minutes for my table which was good because I was early anyway. When my party arrived I went up to the host stand to inform him that my party was all there and he told me my table was still not available and I would have to wait a few minutes longer. We waited what was about 30 minutes. I approached him and he got a bit snippy with me about having to wait. He said something like he cannot force people to leave the table. If you ask me it was just bad organization on his part. So we finally got to our table and it was all the way against the far wall by a window. nice table. The server an older man, came after about 10 minutes took our drink orders and didn't come back with them for another 10. To make a long story short. The salads took forever, the food was O.K. but for the price not good enough, and my mother's birthday was ruined by the servers bad attitude and his complete incompetence. I will never be back to that place. I will also make sure to tell all my friends. The worst part was, the owner not only had a bad attitude in the first place but he did nothing to make our time better even after having spent over $300 dollars.