Reviews for Old Grist Mill Tavern

08/01/2025 - G. Richard Kelly
My wife & I were at The Grist Mill on July 31 and had Shauna C. as our waitress. She did a tremendous job taking care of us. Thank you for having her on your staff.

05/04/2024 - Genie R.
Great food!

01/05/2023 - Paul
This place looks so nice at Christmas with the decorations and live piano music on Wednesdays. Good food too. A great restaurant!

08/06/2022 - MenuPix User
Wasn't to happy today I had twin lobster my husband had prime rib it wasn't cooked the way he wanted it

05/22/2021 - MenuPix User
It has been over 60 years since I made three memorable visits to Old Grist Mill. One was a birthday celebration for three female relatives,now gone, as my guests. The next was as a future bride feted by copy girls at the Providence Journal. The last was a dinner with close friends. Each experience was one I entered into my happy book of memories. Thanks for the memory.

09/28/2019 - K. FOLTZ
MY BROTHER TOOK ME THERE LAST NIGHT FOR MY 65TH BIRTHDAY AND IS WASN'T A GREAT EXPERIENCE AS FAR AS THE FOOD!! OVERCOOKED LOBSTER SENT IT BACK TOUGH LOBSTER AGAIN!! HAD A RIBEYE STEAK MY BROTHER AND I WASN'T FLAVORFUL AND WAS TOUGH!!! WAITRESS WAS GOOD!!! SPENT OVER 150 DOLLARS AND LEFT A 30 DOLLAR TIP!!! EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED!!!