Reviews for O'Toole's Pub

07/29/2025 - Brandon J.
This dive bar has an awesome Irish vibe, great service, and some of the best bar pizza I've had in a while-especially the pastrami and pickle combo. The atmosphere is lively and friendly, with strong drinks, tasty pub food, and plenty of TVs for catching the game, making it a go-to for good times and solid eats.

04/10/2022 - Ml
Great small pub
Their signature pastrami & pickle pizza is the best new combo I've tried in a long time.
Guinness is spot on and lots of other choices for the wife
Regulars were welcoming and the owner was super nice.

03/13/2022 - mad
Great small Irish Pub with lots of history. Bar pizza with Pastrami & Pickle was delicious. Fun environment where on your first visit you feel like family

01/04/2022 - Fantastic
Everything thing was perfect. The food, the service, the atmosphere. I would give it 6 stars if i could!

10/04/2020 - Denise
Absolutely the best home pub food around and hands down amazing bar pizza on the south shore!
The staff are the best

06/08/2020 - Alan Lyons
Great place.
Great food, at great prices
Great service
Great place to pick up women.
Everytime I go in I get Hammered!
Awesome atmosphere

01/26/2020 - Ml
Great bar pizza and the Guinness was a perfect pour 🍀

01/20/2020 - MenuPix User
Great food, pizza was awesome!!!

10/11/2014 - sam
absolute dive , dont go in cook is gross