Reviews for Sebastian Pizza

02/07/2025 - Fernando R.
This pizza is absolutely the best I've encountered, with a sweet sauce that I adore. The crust is crispy and not greasy, making every bite enjoyable. Even after years of trying various pizza spots, this one consistently impresses with its delicious toppings and friendly service.

04/22/2024 - Nate D.
Always wonderful!

08/18/2023 - D Muise
Best pizza in town!!

07/16/2023 - Pam
Sebastian's pizza is delicious. Been goin there for years and it's always great!
Thanks for working so hard and being so nice to your customers.

07/11/2023 - M. Muise
1st time ordering an antipasto salad here and I was very happy with it . Not only will I get probably 4 meals from it , but it was fresh and had plenty of flavor that I didn't use the dressing that they provided on the side . Best salad ever !

03/05/2023 - Dave P.
Best in town!

09/29/2022 - MenuPix User
not even close to what it used to be !!!!!!!!!!

09/25/2022 - Paula G.
Only place to get thick crust pizza! Always excellent!

08/27/2022 - MenuPix User
You are going to loose business if you don't answer your phone

12/20/2020 - Richard
Moved to Gloucester 20 years ago from Long Islander NY, worked in NY City and had many different pizzas.
Only 4 years ago I was introduced to Sebastian's Pizza, wish I knew earlier!! Truly the best pizza I have ever had, the dough is fantastic, the service is. Excellent and prices fair.

07/21/2020 - MenuPix User
Best pizza in Gloucester!

05/31/2020 - Anonymous pizza lover
What happened to sebastians!?!?!? 😩😩😩😩 thing greasy bitter sauced pizzas for much more money than before. Always soo sad when i have to find somewhere else because its never going to be like i remember anymore. R.I
P best sweet sauce pizza in town