Reviews for I Love Ny Pizza

04/17/2025 - Carol C.
I'm a bit puzzled by some of the reviews I've seen. This pizza joint has the best pizza around Milton, Woodstock, and Alpharetta, plus the other menu items are solid too. The owner is super nice, but it could use a little warmth-like, literally, heat up the dipping sauce and keep the door closed to keep the chill out!

09/09/2024 - Danae H.
The pizza at this establishment is hands down the best we've found in the Milton, Woodstock, Alpharetta, Holly Springs area. The other menu items are just as impressive. The owner is friendly, and while the ambiance may not be fancy, the food more than makes up for it. A couple of small improvements could make this place even better, like serving the dipping sauce warm and keeping the door closed for a more comfortable dining experience.

05/29/2024 - Louis N.
great food

05/14/2011 - New in Town from NY!
I LOVE the eggplant rollatini - I have to force myself to try something new each time I go, and I;m never disappointed...linguini with clams, calzones, the cheesesteak stromboli - all awesome! We eat here at least once/week, and it's always great!

08/30/2010 - Molly
The Pizza here is GREAT!! One slice is huge and it taste fabulous! The crust is a little to crunchy but the taste of the pizza overturns it. The Garlic Knots are 2 for $1 and they are AMAZING!!! Cant Wait to try more.

12/05/2009 - MenuPix User
good pizza, and calzones