Reviews for Poor Gary's Pizza

02/21/2025 - Jaden E.
This charming pizza shop takes me back to simpler times before chain restaurants took over small towns, with a wonderfully friendly staff that makes every visit enjoyable. The chicken wild rice pizza is a standout, and they even deliver right to the lake dock, making it perfect for a lakeside meal!

07/05/2024 - Nica H.
good

09/07/2023 - David Gervais
We really enjoyed our meal it was great food and very welcoming staff. A very clean place and we enjoyed the decor. We will be back and tell others about this place. Thank you for a great experience.

02/07/2023 - D'Aysha
my friends told me it good

12/07/2022 - MenuPix User
Always great food and service! Grateful to have delivery in a small town

03/16/2020 - Lisa McCorison
Always good pizza. Excellent delivery and customer service. Very nice folks!

02/12/2020 - MenuPix User
Love their pizza. Quick delivery. Look forward to visit restaurant and try other options on their menu.

09/17/2019 - MenuPix User
Nummy pizza! Excellent customer service and delivery as well. :)

08/15/2018 - James M.
Food is actually very good. I had to deduct a star because far too often delivery times are long. It even takes a long time sometimes when you dine in. Just ask before you order how long it will be. Make sure you have the time.

08/09/2015 - Unhappy customer
This place doesn't deserve 1star! Worst customer service ever! Waited over an hour and a half for pizza. I called a couple times wondering where my pizza was and if I could get a deal cause they told me 40 min delivery. Lady was extremely rude!!!!! lady said they don't give out free food when all I wanted was a discount for the horrible service. I vote this place gets shut down!! DO NOT stop...DO NOT order and DO NOT contribute a penny to this horrible business!!!!!

08/05/2010 - jpjim
Good Pizza at the right Price,Fast Friendly Service

04/29/2010 - Steve
Very good pizza at a competitive price. The price is starting to inch up there so watch PG's or you won't be competitive anymore. The last price increase almost put you out of the running!!!!