Reviews for Andy's Pizza

05/15/2025 - Andrew M.
I found some incredible pizza here that really hits the spot, and trust me, I've searched high and low for something this good since moving around. The service was super friendly, the food was delicious, and I can't wait to come back and explore more of the menu!

07/28/2024 - Not H.
The pizza at Andy's is a delicious find for us, coming from northern New Jersey. The crust is just right, not too thick, not too thin. The Stromboli and pizza rolls are a must-try, and the salads are loaded with fresh ingredients. The service is friendly, the portions are generous, and the prices are great - a true gem in town.

08/09/2020 - MenuPix User
Exceptional!

08/08/2020 - COA NDH
We absolutely loved the pizza, and the staff were very friendly, great service!

08/08/2020 - Andrew Pi
as a fellow Andy, the service and food were phenomenal, as well as the name. 10/5 definitely recommending this to all of my pizza enthusiasts!

03/29/2020 - Pat F
Andy's pizza is the closest to real Italian NY pizza which is hard to find in WV You can fold the slice to do the Lodi crease the Italian way to eat pizza The dough is just right not soggy like most pizza shops and in WV Just we IU sh there was an Andy's closer to where I live in Morgan County