Reviews for Mario's Bakery

08/01/2025 - Krystal K.
The aroma of freshly baked bread and cookies immediately draws you in, and it's easy to leave with more than intended because everything is so irresistible. This bakery offers a wonderful selection of house-made breads, including olive loaf, ciabatta, and various filled pastas, all crafted with care and served by friendly, attentive staff. Although cash is preferred to avoid ATM fees, the quality and authenticity of their products make every visit worthwhile.

07/14/2024 - Kaili S.
Good food, good prices!

07/07/2024 - Lucky D.
The bakery's inviting aroma of freshly baked bread and cookies draws you in, where you'll be tempted to purchase more than just a week's worth of goodies, reminiscent of old-time bakeries, offering a variety of filled pastas, homemade tubular pasta, and an array of delicious loaves perfect for any occasion.

07/09/2022 - Donna Hillman
The best rolls ever. So soft. Great for sausage and peppers sandwiches. Sometimes I get lucky and they have just taken them out of the oven..Yum..

04/16/2022 - Joe Tama
Excellent breads. Best Italian bread since I lived off Arthur Avenue in the Bronx.

11/10/2021 - Ann O'Herron
Good customer service. Freshest ingredients

03/18/2021 - MenuPix User
Great bread

03/04/2021 - MenuPix User
Their home made pasta reminds me of my grandma's. Delicious!!

12/19/2020 - MenuPix User
Best ever!

06/11/2020 - Suzanne
Best Italian bread, pasta and zeppolies

01/06/2020 - Maggie
Best bread ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

06/03/2019 - Robin.
Best bread in NY!!!

05/26/2019 - MenuPix User
Best crumb cake by far ANYWHERE!!!