Reviews for Pizza Cellar

02/26/2024 - MenuPix User

02/16/2024 - MenuPix User

01/23/2024 - MenuPix User

12/14/2023 - MenuPix User

11/15/2023 - MenuPix User

03/24/2023 - Castilisa
We’re new to the area, and we’re thankful to discover the Pizza Cellar! We love their pizza; definitely our go to place for pizza!

09/05/2022 - MenuPix User
Dirty ,and not the same business.

05/04/2022 - MenuPix User
Expensive for cardboard crust and jar ingredients. It isn't the same place. Dirty. Too bad...

08/28/2020 - Joe
its really cool and unique place awesome pizza and chicken wings! On our return list for sure!

07/12/2020 - McFarland
Great place of history, always welcoming and friendly. The perfect place to eat some super good food!!! It's a must if visiting or local!!

07/11/2020 - Mike
Terrible!
Watch your money & your change you get back.
Don't expect clean & don't expect to be able to finish your meal before they put it in a tho bag that they staple shut.
Before you can finish what is on your plate they ask you if your ready to pay for it.
Don't exit be treated fairly when you ask for no olives but have pepper on the side. They charged $2.10 for your peppers & wont substitute for what you don't want on it.
We use to love this place & told a lot of friends about it but not anymore & WILL NOT drive out of our way or return to la pizza cellar. This place has become nasty & know you will only be there that one last time plus see you coming. Please don't waste your time or money here anymore. They are just flat out mean.

05/04/2015 - scott allan
i was really disappointed with this place for all the hype it gets, wont go back glad I just bought a small. I ordered 1 with everything not very many toppings and crust was hard as rock but sauce was good, sat. may 2nd around 5 oclock.

08/29/2012 - Doug
I have been eating Pizza here for almost my whole life. They have amazing thin crust pizza. If you like pizza with everything, order "The Special" and a pitcher of beer. Dennis and his staff also have a great full bar. The atmosphere is always relaxed and laid back. It does feel like you walk into a Cellar. For anyone visiting the Branson Tri-lakes area Pizza Cellar is a must.

02/03/2010 - Larry
Thankfully we asked the waitress for recommendation--she recommended we start with their pizzas. Rustic digs with decent drinks, and absolutely world-class pizza. Some other diners were having various other Italian-style meals that looked worth trying. If you only have time for one meal stop in the area, (including Branson), the Pizza Cellar in Rockaway Beach is THE place. Cost are quite reasonable. Walk-ins and street digs seem to work. fyi: I believe their phone number is 417.561.4709.