Reviews for Douglas & James Homemade Ice Cream

06/03/2025 - Hali M.
The ice cream here is incredibly creamy and bursting with fresh, rich flavors, making every bite irresistible. With a wide variety of unique options and generous mix-ins like Oreo chunks and brownie pieces, each scoop feels like a special treat. The charming atmosphere, friendly staff, and beautiful waterfront views create the perfect setting to enjoy a delicious dessert experience that keeps me coming back again and again.

06/17/2024 - David K.
Douglas & James is the best homemade ice cream spot on Long Island's North Shore, where I indulged in their addictive maple walnut in a waffle cone almost every day during my week-long visit from L.A., enjoying the creamy, fresh flavors and the charming, antique ambiance by the water.

05/12/2024 - Bridget J.
Excellent food, good service.