Reviews for Captain Ben's Fish Market

02/19/2025 - Clare T.
This seafood store has become my go-to due to its friendly staff, exceptional quality and prices, and the wonderful experience it provides for my daughter, making every visit enjoyable while offering delicious options like lobster bisque and fried seafood.

06/30/2022 - MT
The food is at least terrible and overpriced. For $18 you can get a hamburger with fries that makes McDonald's burger look like a delicatessen. Dry, small, no cheese or sauce, just bread, patty lettuce. The bisque soup was decent. The tacos(if you like a tortilla wrap with a piece of fried fish and a slice of lime) were dry and not what expected for mid-'20s. The calamari was very basic, again not what you would expect from a fish market restaurant. The same with the shrimps. The service takes a century to serve you. It is a great place to get a beer and then go to a serious restaurant to eat.

11/09/2021 - Lew B
Always fresh, Always friendly & helpful!

08/19/2017 - Kevin P.Sullivan
MMMMM- Fresh Lobsters from Our Friends. at CAPTAIN BEN'S FISH MARKET

Where Customers can select their own fish and feel always WELCOME like Friends and Family - Just Ask For My Good Friend Dan are anyone from their exuberant staff don't be afraid to speak up friends and friends of friends are always welcome so tell All of yours where to go...

CAPTAIN BEN'S FISH MARKET 361 Woodcleft Ave.Freeport,NY 11520 Call 516-378-6575 ..

And Say Kevin P Sullivan of NYC Brooklyn said you have The Best Long Island Sound Lobsters and the freshest fish in Long Island

something to consider bring your cooler their prices are very family-friendly and while they're preparing your order take a seat and have something to eat myself and Joanna,along with my mom and sisters always love the fresh clams on a half shell.

and then go for a stroll and enjoy the beautiful views take in some sea air and just relax On The Nautical Mile