Reviews for Sayville Chocolatier

08/24/2025 - Lord S.
Every holiday season, choosing chocolates carefully for my daughter's father-in-law is a delicate task due to his almond allergy, and this cozy shop made the selection so much easier with the help of a cheerful, knowledgeable young lady. The moment I stepped inside, the rich aroma of freshly made chocolates enveloped me, promising an indulgent experience that was confirmed with each bite of the dark chocolates and creamy truffles we shared, sparking joy around the gift exchange. The quaint atmosphere, attentive service, and exquisite handcrafted treats create an inviting warmth that lingers long after leaving, making it a cherished stop whenever I seek something truly special.

05/31/2024 - Kayla M.
I always make a point to find the perfect chocolates for my daughter's father-in-law, who has a nut allergy, and recently discovered a charming store where the staff went above and beyond to help me select suitable options. The dark chocolates I purchased for my husband at the same store were exceptionally delicious, and I was impressed by the wide selection of handmade treats available.

05/25/2024 - Adam H.
Great food and staff

07/20/2020 - Dan
I have been going here for 30+ years. The service is very friendly and the variety of chocolates and hard candies is excellent.