Reviews for Wise Guys Pizza

06/10/2025 - Brittany P.
Having tasted authentic Chicago-style pizza before, this version impressively surpasses it with a generous layering of cheese and toppings that create an explosion of flavor in every bite. Despite a slightly overcooked crust one time, the deep dish and stuffed pizzas deliver a delectably saucy, fresh, and doughy experience that keeps me coming back whenever I'm in Columbia.

02/23/2025 - Alexis C.
The deep dish and stuffed pizzas here are incredibly good, with an abundance of cheese and toppings that really elevate the experience. Despite some recent price increases, the flavors and quality make it a must-visit for any pizza lover in Columbia.

09/30/2009 - MenuPix User
Worst customer service I have ever experienced. I was told 45min to 1 hour for delivery, waited 1-1/2 hours to have a pizza and salad delivered to a hotel without utensils. They knew the address was a hotel, the delivery person just said sorry when I questioned if she brought a fork for me. I called to talked to manager at store and he seemed bothered by my call when told him problem with late delivery and no utensils. I told him the least he could do is act like he cared if the customer was not satisfied and he stated “this is just how I talk, do you want me to send out a fork?” I told him not if it would take another hour and he said ok. Would not recommend!!! I am in sales now but had been in food service for 15 years and would never tolerate treating a customer that way!