Reviews for Gardner Pie

04/14/2025 - Sean C.
This pie shop is an absolute treasure for anyone who loves delicious pastries. With an impressive capacity of 50,000 pies made daily, they offer an incredible variety including fresh, frozen, and cream options at unbeatable prices. I've been a loyal customer for years, and every pie I've tried has been exceptional, making it impossible to resist returning for more.

06/19/2024 - Perla S.
AWESOME!

06/11/2024 - Gold S.
This pie shop offers a wide variety of fresh, frozen, and cream pies that are delicious, affordable, and available for worldwide shipping, with a production capacity of 50,000 pies per day.

08/17/2023 - Margaret Frost
Always a pleasant experience. Helpful courteous personnel. Best pies ever. Our family get togethers (there are a lot of them & we are are a big family) would feel strange without a dessert from Gardner pies.

08/10/2023 - Bob orr
Great pies good price very friendly employees!

04/08/2023 - Cathy Bondurant
Great pies. Staff great. Should have made more strawberry pies on Easter weekend. Already sold out at 10a.m.?

08/02/2020 - A, Hudak
Purchased two of the vegetable pies and they were great. Pie crust is amazing. However, I purchased the Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie and literally went into a "sugar shock". My tongue felt weird and my heart rate elevated rapidly. I had to lay down. It was like a person having a peanut reaction. I felt awful all day.
Pies are way tooooo sweet and helps me understand why people say they love them. We live in a society of excessive sugar. If there was a nutritional label on the pie box, I am certain it would have been in excess of 40 grams of sugar. I took only the one bite and had to spit if out. I certainly hope you maintain a money back guarantee because now I am stuck with a whole pie. Additionally I purchased a Pecan Pie but will not even cut into it. So that is 2 pies. I now see that you put brown sugar and syrup in those pies. Sugar could be cut more than 1/2 to make it an acceptable pie. I know you have sugar free but does that mean sucralose??? which is just as bad. Those two pies turned me off completely.