Reviews for Gardner Pie

08/17/2023 - Margaret Frost
Always a pleasant experience. Helpful courteous personnel. Best pies ever. Our family get togethers (there are a lot of them & we are are a big family) would feel strange without a dessert from Gardner pies.

08/10/2023 - Bob orr
Great pies good price very friendly employees!

04/08/2023 - Cathy Bondurant
Great pies. Staff great. Should have made more strawberry pies on Easter weekend. Already sold out at 10a.m.?

08/02/2020 - A, Hudak
Purchased two of the vegetable pies and they were great. Pie crust is amazing. However, I purchased the Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie and literally went into a "sugar shock". My tongue felt weird and my heart rate elevated rapidly. I had to lay down. It was like a person having a peanut reaction. I felt awful all day.
Pies are way tooooo sweet and helps me understand why people say they love them. We live in a society of excessive sugar. If there was a nutritional label on the pie box, I am certain it would have been in excess of 40 grams of sugar. I took only the one bite and had to spit if out. I certainly hope you maintain a money back guarantee because now I am stuck with a whole pie. Additionally I purchased a Pecan Pie but will not even cut into it. So that is 2 pies. I now see that you put brown sugar and syrup in those pies. Sugar could be cut more than 1/2 to make it an acceptable pie. I know you have sugar free but does that mean sucralose??? which is just as bad. Those two pies turned me off completely.