Reviews for Heritage Amish Bake Shoppe

05/31/2025 - Olga G.
The monster cookies here are hands down the best I've ever tasted, and their pies-from pecan to rhubarb with a crisp topping-always hit the perfect balance of sweetness. Every visit feels like coming home, with friendly staff, the irresistible aroma of fresh-baked goods, and a wonderful selection of Amish-made treats that keep me coming back for weekly snacks and holiday desserts.

09/07/2024 - Shannon M.
Their monster cookies are the best I've ever had, along with a variety of other delectable treats.

06/11/2024 - Nanette M.
Creamy

02/06/2023 - MenuPix User
Great pastries and wonderful people

11/16/2022 - WADE SCHWEITZER
Wonderful people - Great bakery - Year-round!
Quality Amish furniture down the hall!

04/25/2022 - Joy - VB
Gotta have their everything muffins and coffee cakes. Once you've tasted them you'll crave for more.

08/01/2021 - MenuPix User
Amazing cinnamon rolls & blueberry pie. My new favorite bakery!

07/30/2021 - MenuPix User
All you can say is dang everything is great and a child can read the ingredients real stuff

06/12/2021 - MenuPix User
The best molasses cookies in existence. I am addicted to having one with my morning coffee every day.

06/01/2021 - Carol D.
Received a fresh strawberry pie, and I have to say, IT'S THE BEST PIE I'VE EVER EATEN!!! THANK YOU!!!! 🍓🍓🍰🍓🍓
Made with LOVE 😇

04/07/2021 - Carolyn
I call this my happy place whenever you go in to. the bakery everyone is happy greats you and the smells are wonderfully. Thank you

11/03/2020 - John C.
Great bakery with wide range of products and great service always provided with pleasantries!!!! Love coming here!!

04/07/2020 - Jo-Ann
Have always been satisfied with any purchases from this store! Everything is always fresh!

02/08/2019 - MenuPix User
Fantastic!

11/17/2017 - Daniel Miller
These people know how to bake! Great food, great staff, great service!