Reviews for Michaelangelo's Southold

04/15/2025 - Easton P.
I often stop at Michaelangelo Southold before or after visiting vineyards, enjoying their delicious pizza and specialty slices. The chicken Cordon Bleu and filet mignon specials were flavorful and perfectly cooked, complemented by attentive service and a pleasant atmosphere, making it a restaurant I look forward to returning to.

12/09/2024 - Alfred M.
I often swing by before or after hitting up the vineyards around here. Long Island pizza is solid - not NYC caliber, but definitely hits the spot with their loaded specialty slices. The staff is friendly, the food is tasty, and the outdoor seating is a nice touch - definitely a spot worth revisiting.

05/25/2024 - Mary K.
Food is great!

08/29/2022 - Madeleine
We've had many great meals both in the restaurant and take out. Their food is consistently good. Portions are generous and the staff works hard to keep the customers happy. My favorite!

08/11/2022 - Glo
Excellent Italian food!! Sometimes a bit slow due to staffing problems, but always well worth the wait! Love 'people watching' on the veranda - always a lot to see at this very popular restaurant.

02/03/2020 - Kirk Coy
Great food & always good service