Reviews for Uncle Mikey's Brick Oven Pizza

06/12/2025 - Kimmie M.
Uncle Mikey's serves amazing pizza and Italian dishes with friendly, attentive service that makes you feel right at home. The owner's charm and generosity, like surprising us with a free slice of cheesecake, truly enhance the dining experience and keep me coming back.

07/02/2022 - Paula
Best pizza I ever ate!!!!

01/07/2022 - MenuPix User
Delicious and down-home feel to the restaurant. Mikey's special pizza is the best, but be hungry if you order.

01/05/2022 - Frankie
The best I have ever had!!!

10/19/2021 - Sur
Scrumptious

10/19/2021 - Sur
Scrumptious h

11/20/2020 - Kathy K
If you eat here, you're familia!! Mikey is the BEST!! He really is part of the community and is always bringing a smile (and most likely a pizza) to someone in need. Welove Uncle Mikey!!

10/11/2020 - Alice
Love the friendly atmosphere! Good is great!

04/18/2020 - Jim
Mostly because they're good people but the food is awesome too

04/09/2020 - Bill
The best Italian food in the area...
Best pizza, competes with the best of NYC

02/19/2020 - Glenn & Kathleen Prentice
Absolutely the best Italian food!! Casual atmosphere with personal service. Mikey himself greets every customer and visits tables. Staff friendly and professional- service is fabulous. Each meal and wine is delicious!! Highly recommend.....

10/26/2018 - Marianne and Lou
Uncle Mikey's is the very BEST in the area. I am half Italian and his food is the real deal. Friendly and inviting way about him -- not promoting himself as the master chef with outrageous prices. Uncle Mikey makes people feel as though they are visiting his home for dinner. Love this man and so will you.

04/14/2017 - Joanne Carroll
Wait at 7:00 pm on a Thursday with a reservation was 15 minutes or more . It was not that busy. Again, the wait for a waitress was extremely long, with constant apology thanking us for our patience. Dinners were fair....I have been there for pizza which was very good..would go back for pizza but not dinner.

01/23/2017 - pattyanne
BEST pizza in the Inlet by far! We are from New England and until we found Uncle Mikeys, we never thought we would find such great pizza!!!!

11/29/2016 - Marshall
Good pizza but disappointed. I expected a wood fore brick over but it's not. It is a brick oven not wood fired.