Reviews for All Star Pizza & Italian Restaurant

06/13/2025 - Angela M.
Growing up enjoying their pizza, I've always appreciated the consistent quality and the crispy, flavorful dough that keeps me coming back, especially for their onion rings and garlic rolls. The staff's friendly service and the variety of unique menu options, like the chicken marsala pizza and homemade pasta fagioli, make every visit a great experience.

06/13/2024 - Rachael J.
I have been a loyal customer of All Star Pizza since childhood and have consistently enjoyed their delicious offerings over the years. The crispy and flavorful onion rings, along with the well-made pizza dough, have always been standout favorites for me. Despite a minor disappointment with the mozzarella sticks, the overall experience of ordering from this location has been a pleasant and satisfying one.

05/25/2024 - Ben H.
Good Food

11/01/2022 - MenuPix User
First time delivery last night. One of two best eggplant parmigiana I have EVER had. Excellent flavor & consistency. Multiple items ordered were high quality. Very good customer service.

03/28/2019 - Camille
The pizza is always great. The wings don't always come well done & crispy, as I request, but are also great when cooked as I like them. The people, especially the lady (sorry I can't remember her name) who takes the orders is always nice and friendly. Time of arrival is usually on point too.